11 Comments

“Today’s NIMBYism, though it gathers under the rallying cry ‘Not in my backyard,’ is not actually concerned with individual people and their property, either. It’s not ‘my backyard’ but rather somebody else’s backyard they’re talking about—and seeking to control.“

Amazing quote 🙌🏻

Expand full comment

Thanks! Amazing handle, by the way. I've been flâneuring my way across France the past two weeks.

Expand full comment

Thank you! That's awesome, dude. I was in Paris a couple years ago and had a blast. Infrastructure there is beautiful. The Pont de Bir-Hakeim bridge is amazing, it's got these amazing steel sculptures on the side.

Expand full comment

I'm a little late to this post, but enjoyed it thoroughly. Thoughtful and fair. The ghost of Robert Moses also hangs over the mismanaging (in my opinion) of the future of the BQE, one of my white whales.

https://brianhoward.substack.com/p/the-brooklyn-queens-expressway-how?r=c50dd

Expand full comment

Thanks, Brian! I've loosely followed the reconstruction saga for the Brooklyn Heights section of the BQE, and I wonder if this is another instance where the world would have been different if Moses had liked to build tunnels.

Expand full comment

The 99pi series is incredible

Expand full comment

Yes! It's been excellent.

Expand full comment

Interesting article. I have never had the guts to plow through all 1200 pages of “The Power Broker.” It was simply too long.

Your article clearly illustrate the trade-offs involved in large-scale construction projects within densely-populated urban centers. The unchecked power of Robert Moses and the massive web of checks by NIMBYs are two extremes to be avoided, but I am not sure where the best balances lays.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Michael! It's a beast of a book! I recommend it as a literary work in its own right, but it requires context and further reading (like the other book I mentioned, "Robert Moses & the Modern City") to get a fuller, more nuanced picture of the history. That said, I think Caro ably demonstrates Moses's character.

Beyond that, yes, these are definitely complicated questions!

Expand full comment

Love the Ozymandias Revisited quote!

Expand full comment

When I think of Moses I automatically think of that poem.

Expand full comment